No prison after brutal attack: What the settlement means for Mallorca and the victims

No prison after brutal attack: What the settlement means for Mallorca and the victims

A cash payment instead of prison — and many unanswered questions

At the taxi rank in the harbor, where in the mornings the coffee aromas from the cafés mix with the diesel clouds from the ferries, the drivers are already talking about the settlement: Three German police officers from Essen have paid the 71-year-old colleague, who in August was so seriously injured that he spent several days in hospital, a payment of around €50,000. In return the criminal proceedings are to end without imprisonment — the decision now lies with the court in Palma; this has been reported in Trial in Essen: Four Germans charged over alleged incident in Mallorca.

Main question: Are monetary payments sufficient as a substitute for criminal accountability when physical violence has serious consequences and the perpetrators are officers?

The facts are sparse: During the assault after a night of partying on the Playa de Palma a dispute over an allegedly lost mobile phone is said to have escalated. The driver suffered injuries, including broken ribs and a blood clot in the head; the allegedly stolen phone was later found in a backpack belonging to the defendants. According to the victim's lawyer, the parties involved, including the prosecution, agreed to a settlement; the payment is intended to cover both compensation for pain and suffering and legal costs.

Critical analysis: At first glance the deal appears pragmatic — a victim receives money quickly, and the justice system saves trial time. At second glance it is a problematic mechanism. If officers whose job is to protect people use violence against civilians and this can be settled with a financial arrangement, a trust deficit arises. Equality before the law is shaken because punishment in this case is replaced by compensation.

What is missing in the public discourse: The perspective of the taxi community itself. Among the drivers who begin their shifts in the morning on Avinguda Gabriel Alomar there is talk of unease: What consequences does this have for their personal safety at work? There is also no clear information about how the payment is divided: Did all three police officers pay equally, and who bears responsibility in terms of service and criminal law in Germany? It also remains unclear how quickly the files will be transmitted from Palma to the authorities in Essen after the settlement is finalised so that possible disciplinary measures can follow there.

An everyday scene in Mallorca: An older taxi driver, weathered by years of work, says in passing that since the summer he has been even more cautious, especially at night on the Playa. The bars are full, voices loud, and nobody wants to be drawn into a physical fight. In the corner bar the waitress shakes her head: 'We haven't had anything like this with German police before,' she says, without naming names — but with a look that says a lot here.

Concrete solutions: First, clear cross-border information obligations between judicial authorities: files on serious allegations should be exchanged within defined timeframes so that interior ministries do not have to stand by idle. Second, in cases of serious bodily harm by members of security forces a temporary suspension from duty should be considered until investigations are complete; that prevents the impression of leniency. Third, independent complaint offices at regional level could advise victims and accompany proceedings so that payments are not the only form of taking responsibility. Fourth, mandatory de-escalation and human rights training for officers before overseas deployments would have a preventive effect.

Bottom line: A settlement is not a verdict. For the injured person the payment may mean quick help; for the community it is no substitute for public accountability. Mallorca is everyday life — loud, sunny, sometimes rough. When police officers here appear as assailants, it affects not just one taxi driver but trust in law enforcement overall. Court decisions and internal disciplinary measures must become transparent, otherwise the impression remains: Those who wear a uniform buy their way out with money, a concern reflected in coverage such as Palmanova verdict: Two years in prison — and what Mallorca must learn now and Suspended Sentence After Abuse in Palmanova: A Verdict That Raises More Questions.