Satellite detects longlines in Llevant protected area – severe penalties and unanswered questions

Satellite detects longlines in Llevant protected area – severe penalties and unanswered questions

In the morning, when the Port de Manacor still smelled of diesel and freshly smoked fish and the seagulls circled the quay walls, the talk on the pier was not about the weather but about a boat "in the wrong place." The Directorate for Fisheries confirms: a professional fisherman is alleged to have fished with longlines (palangre) in the Llevant marine protected area — a method explicitly prohibited there.

Monitoring by satellite: how the "green box" reveals misconduct

It was not a passerby or the coast guard who noticed the offense, but the satellite-based monitoring system known as the "green box." According to the authority, the images provided sufficient evidence to open proceedings. Antoni Maria Grau, Director-General for Fisheries, puts it plainly: "Those who fish in protected areas endanger entire stocks and the work of their colleagues."

For many here on the east coast, that seems logical — inspections at sea are demanding, with wind, short nights and complex stretches of coast making patrols difficult. Satellites provide a kind of eye from space that does not sleep. But is a pixel image enough to destroy livelihoods?

Why the issue is more complicated than a photo

The central question is: how do we find a balance between effective monitoring and fair treatment of professional fishermen? Satellite data are powerful but not infallible. Clouds, course changes and evasive maneuvers can complicate interpretations. Some people here say the rules are not enforced equally everywhere; others fear that individuals could abuse the system to report competitors.

Less often discussed is how stricter controls shift behavior: will illegal fishing be displaced to other, less monitored areas? Or will smaller boats that traditionally work along the coast be disproportionately affected while larger units operate evasively? And: who verifies the satellite data, who has access to the raw data, and how transparent is the process?

Consequences for stocks and people

Longlines can severely damage the seabed and juvenile fish stocks — in protected areas like Llevant, where seagrass meadows and growth zones are nursery grounds for young fish, this is particularly dangerous. The authority is threatening fines of up to €60,000 and the revocation of fishing licenses. For a family in Port de Manacor, that can be ruinous; for the stock it could provide relief.

Here, two legitimate interests collide: the protection of sensitive ecosystems and securing livelihoods. The deterrent strategy has its effect, but deterrence alone does not replace lost quotas or provide social cushioning for those affected.

What would help now

Instead of only punishing, a package of monitoring, prevention and support is needed. Some proposals that would make sense locally:

1. Transparent data and clear standards: Satellite data should be disclosable and standardized for inspections so that cases are not judged subjectively. A notification and appeal period for those affected is necessary.

2. Combined monitoring: Satellite, AIS/GPS trackers on vessels, spot inspections and local observers — only the combination increases legal certainty.

3. Differentiated sanctions: Fines scaled by severity, and alternative measures such as mandatory training, temporary caps or assistance to switch gear instead of immediate license withdrawal for first offenses.

4. Support programs: Retraining, grants to transition to more selective fishing methods or a voluntary buy-back program for particularly harmful gear.

5. Local co-management models: Fishing communities, conservationists and authorities at the table — shared maps, clearly defined protected zones and realistic time windows can increase acceptance.

Outlook: strict, but socially balanced

The authorities' message is clear: protected area means protected area. But long-term success requires more than high fines. Those who work here on the quay hear the waves, see the seagrass meadows in the clear water and know: ecology and economy are linked. A purely punitive policy can create calm in the short term — sustainable solutions emerge where monitoring, transparency and social support come together.

The hope of coastal communities is simple: fair, comprehensible rules that protect stocks while securing livelihoods. And who knows — perhaps satellites will not only lead to prosecutions but also to better conversations over breakfast at the harbour, when the sun rises over Llevant and the boats head out again.